Key Takeaways

    Peter Thiel’s Thiel Macro sold all of its American Electric Power, DTE Energy and FirstEnergy stock by Sept. 30. Those positions made up 29% of the fund at June 30, and in the same quarter it added 59% to its Vista Energy stake.

    All three utilities have since reported higher third-quarter earnings, and AEP and DTE raised their long-term growth targets.

    Analysts’ average targets sit 7% to 9% above each stock’s price, and AEP’s is the only one that has climbed much over the past year.

    AEP looks like the sale the numbers back least, while FirstEnergy’s slower growth makes it the easiest exit to understand.

    Peter Thiel just cleared three utilities out of his fund. Thiel Macro’s 13F for the quarter ended Sept. 30, filed Nov. 16, shows it no longer owns American Electric Power (AEP), DTE Energy (DTE) or FirstEnergy (FE). It held all three on June 30.

    Nearly a third of the fund, gone

    Together, the three made up 29% of the fund at June 30: 308,617 shares of AEP worth $42 million (10.1%), 264,450 shares of DTE worth $40 million (9.6%) and 839,319 shares of FirstEnergy worth $40 million (9.5%). A 13F shows only what a fund held on a quarter’s last day, so it doesn’t say when in the quarter the fund sold, or at what price.

    Since June 30, AEP stock is down 5%, DTE is down 8% and FirstEnergy is flat. (Those are the stocks’ moves from that day’s price. What the fund got for its shares, the 13F doesn’t say.)

    What’s left is concentrated. The 13F now holds $460 million of US stocks in five positions. Vista Energy (VIST) is 26.8% of that after the fund added 59% to its shares in the quarter, and Vista stock is down 18% since Sept. 30.

    TIKR tracks 23 analysts on American Electric Power. How many say “Buy”?

    See the full breakdown of Buy, Hold, and Sell ratings on American Electric Power, along with Wall Street’s revenue and earnings estimates, all in one place. More than 500,000 investors use TIKR to research stocks like this one. See American Electric Power’s Analyst Ratings

    AEP is the hardest sale to defend

    AEP’s third quarter, reported Oct. 28, was a big one. Operating earnings rose to $2.23 a share from $1.80 a year earlier, and management now expects 2026 to land at or above the high end of its $6.25-$6.55 range. It also rolled out a $100 billion five-year capital plan and a new target of 9%-11% annual operating earnings growth from 2027 through 2031. And the demand behind that plan is signed: AEP added 15 gigawatts of new load commitments in the quarter and now has 84 gigawatts of contracted load through 2031, counting only commitments backed by executed agreements.

    Analysts have raised their sights all year. AEP’s average target climbed from $127 to $142 over the past year:

    Line chart from TIKR of American Electric Power's analysts' consensus (mean) price target, $ per share, last year.American Electric Power (AEP): analysts’ consensus (mean) price target, $ per share, last year (TIKR)

    That’s 9% above today’s price, from the 23 analysts who cover it, with the stock at about 19x forward earnings.

    DTE’s plan got bigger too

    DTE told a similar story on its Nov. 5 call. Third-quarter operating earnings came to $2.30 a share, and management said it’s on track for the high end of its 2026 guidance of $7.59-$7.73. It raised its long-term operating EPS growth target to more than 9% and laid out a $44 billion utility investment plan that it ties to data center growth. But it’s also selling its Vantage business for about $3 billion, which management expects to dilute earnings for a while.

    The Street hasn’t budged. DTE’s average target is $151, right where it was a year ago, after peaking at $162 in July:

    Line chart from TIKR of DTE Energy's analysts' consensus (mean) price target, $ per share, last year.DTE Energy (DTE): analysts’ consensus (mean) price target, $ per share, last year (TIKR)

    At about 17x forward earnings, DTE is cheaper than AEP, and the 17 analysts who cover it see 8% upside.

    FirstEnergy’s numbers back the sale best

    FirstEnergy reported first, on Oct. 27, and its quarter was also solid: core earnings rose to $0.98 a share from $0.83 a year earlier. But its outlook is the most modest of the three. It reaffirmed 2026 core earnings guidance of $2.62-$2.82 a share and expects results at or slightly above the midpoint. It sees long-term growth near the top of 6%-8% a year through 2030, backed by a $36 billion five-year capital plan.

    Analysts don’t expect much more than that. FirstEnergy’s average target has crept from $50 to $51 over the past year:

    Line chart from TIKR of FirstEnergy's analysts' consensus (mean) price target, $ per share, last year.FirstEnergy (FE): analysts’ consensus (mean) price target, $ per share, last year (TIKR)

    That’s 7% above today’s price from the 18 analysts who cover it, and the lowest target, $46, is already below the stock. At about 17x forward earnings, FirstEnergy costs about what DTE does, with slower growth.

    AEP is the one I’d want back

    On the numbers, the fund’s exit looks right for FirstEnergy, defensible for DTE and early for AEP. If I could only buy one of the three right now, it’d be AEP. It has the highest growth target, much of its new demand is under contract, and it’s the only one of the three whose average target analysts have kept raising this year. It does cost more, at about 19x forward earnings.

    The risk for all three is the same: plans this big need regulators to approve the rates that pay for them, and DTE has several of those decisions still pending.

    Thiel Macro’s next 13F, due in mid-February, will show whether it stayed out of utilities and whether Vista is still more than a quarter of the fund. And each utility’s fourth-quarter report early next year will show whether those growth plans are holding up.

    So what is American Electric Power stock actually worth?

    TIKR lets you forecast the future price of any stock in less than a minute. Just enter a few assumptions into TIKR’s valuation model and see what American Electric Power could be worth. Start from Wall Street consensus estimates, or adjust the inputs to reflect your own view of the business. It’s free to use.

    Value American Electric Power for free

    Disclaimer:

    Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!

    Comments are closed.