NY city council is about to pass an ordinance forcing all landlords wanting to sell residential buildings with 3 or more units to first offer it up to the city to buy. Then they’re required to allow the city to match private offers that may come in after the city’s initial offer.
cliffotn on
So a broken and bastardized system will become more broken, and more bastardized.
Witness – rent control. Sounds terrific! Except the issue is controlled rent rates don’t keep up with inflation.
So what you say? Those $billionaire landlords just need a thinner profit margin! They just need to be more efficient! That doesn’t work. What happened is when a rent controlled building’s profit margin shrinks enough, there isn’t enough cash on hand to keep up with repairs and maintenance – so the building slowly degrades and becomes a shit hole. Elevators become permanently “closed for repair”, bugs take over, plumbing and electrical issues become rampant. They say then that landlord sucks at their job, sell it to somebody who knows what they’re doing! Ok, but that doesn’t Hailey because of rent control. In reality landlords know how much it’ll toad to repair a building and bring it up to proper condition, so they look at 100 Main Street, which needs $5million or more just to bring it up to a minimum level. They see rent is fixed. They do a simple calculation as to how long it’ll take to break even, and they see it’s a losing proposition. As in they literally can’t collect enough rent to pay the mortgage + renovate the building + maintain the property. So it becomes a shit hole until the City forces them to close until it’s all repaired, then it sits empty as nobody will buy it **because a new owner can’t recoup the investment**.
evilfollowingmb on
NYC appears to choose the wrong solution to every problem with remarkable consistency. It’s almost like they choose ANYTHING that will make a bad situation worse.
3 Comments
Summary for those who can’t stand the ads.
NY city council is about to pass an ordinance forcing all landlords wanting to sell residential buildings with 3 or more units to first offer it up to the city to buy. Then they’re required to allow the city to match private offers that may come in after the city’s initial offer.
So a broken and bastardized system will become more broken, and more bastardized.
Witness – rent control. Sounds terrific! Except the issue is controlled rent rates don’t keep up with inflation.
So what you say? Those $billionaire landlords just need a thinner profit margin! They just need to be more efficient! That doesn’t work. What happened is when a rent controlled building’s profit margin shrinks enough, there isn’t enough cash on hand to keep up with repairs and maintenance – so the building slowly degrades and becomes a shit hole. Elevators become permanently “closed for repair”, bugs take over, plumbing and electrical issues become rampant. They say then that landlord sucks at their job, sell it to somebody who knows what they’re doing! Ok, but that doesn’t Hailey because of rent control. In reality landlords know how much it’ll toad to repair a building and bring it up to proper condition, so they look at 100 Main Street, which needs $5million or more just to bring it up to a minimum level. They see rent is fixed. They do a simple calculation as to how long it’ll take to break even, and they see it’s a losing proposition. As in they literally can’t collect enough rent to pay the mortgage + renovate the building + maintain the property. So it becomes a shit hole until the City forces them to close until it’s all repaired, then it sits empty as nobody will buy it **because a new owner can’t recoup the investment**.
NYC appears to choose the wrong solution to every problem with remarkable consistency. It’s almost like they choose ANYTHING that will make a bad situation worse.