A Grand Strategy of Consolidation

Submission Statement: Former Donald Trump aid Wess Mitchel argues that the United States is overstretched and should focus on rebuilding power at home while narrowing overseas commitments. Drawing parallels with Britain before the first world war, the author says the U.S. should prioritise China and the Western Hemisphere while asking allies in Europe and the Middle East to shoulder more of their own defence. The strategy—called “consolidation”—aims to avoid large wars, rebuild industry and military capacity, and buy time for long-term competition with China. The second administration of Donald Trump is portrayed as already moving in this direction through tariffs, defence reforms, pressure on allies and attempts at détente with Russia and China. But the ongoing war with Iran is seen as the biggest risk: if it drags on, it could undermine the whole strategy. Critics worry rivals could exploit a reduced U.S. presence in other regions, while allies may fear abandonment. Mitchel concludes that sticking to consolidation could give America a “second wind” as a great power if it can resist returning to global overreach.