That’s because Netanyahu is right. To Hamas, this won’t mean anything. At best, it’s a couple years of relative calm, and then they’re back at it, launching rockets into Israel. They will NOT abide by this peace plan.
Countless US Presidents have tried this and failed.
renge-refurion on
Exactly this. Trump wants this peace plan because it is a legacy-defining accomplishment. Nothing wrong with that but you cannot make peace with irrational non-state actors. Hamas is decimated in its current form but some version of radical extremism will rise again in that area unless there is a western-backed (not Arab-backed) government to control the area. The hostages (sad as it is) cannot be traded for a deal that ultimately allows this all to cycle up again in 2-4 years IMO. Only real solution here is to crush what’s left of Gaza city and destroy the remaining tunnels. Israel or a US-backed PK force is going to have to control the borders to ensure they don’t get rebuilt again. No terrorist is going to accept this IMO, so we’re better off letting Israel hammer down the final nail and starting over from that point.
2 Comments
That’s because Netanyahu is right. To Hamas, this won’t mean anything. At best, it’s a couple years of relative calm, and then they’re back at it, launching rockets into Israel. They will NOT abide by this peace plan.
Countless US Presidents have tried this and failed.
Exactly this. Trump wants this peace plan because it is a legacy-defining accomplishment. Nothing wrong with that but you cannot make peace with irrational non-state actors. Hamas is decimated in its current form but some version of radical extremism will rise again in that area unless there is a western-backed (not Arab-backed) government to control the area. The hostages (sad as it is) cannot be traded for a deal that ultimately allows this all to cycle up again in 2-4 years IMO. Only real solution here is to crush what’s left of Gaza city and destroy the remaining tunnels. Israel or a US-backed PK force is going to have to control the borders to ensure they don’t get rebuilt again. No terrorist is going to accept this IMO, so we’re better off letting Israel hammer down the final nail and starting over from that point.